Skip to main content

Share on Twitter

Patient 'was harmed by urology head of department'


Family calls for action against FGH urology consultant




An incident involving a man with a single kidney who had to be taken to intensive care in 2016 because of errors allegedly made by Muhammad Naseem has come to light following an FOI request I made.

The response reveals UHMBT didn't carry out a Root Cause Analysis after the patient was not immediately taken to theatre despite having an infected, obstructed kidney. 

Fortunately Peter Duffy became aware of the case and operated on the man as an emergency.  

The case shows worrying similarities with the circumstances surrounding the deaths of Irene Erhart in 2011 and Peter Read in 2015. 

Peter Read's family said:



“We continue to demand that action is taken against both these consultants. We’re aware Mr Jain has returned to surgery and understand he is being supervised by a doctor junior to himself. When will something be done?

“It is utterly disgraceful that more than a year after dad’s death, when everyone in urology - and the trust, knew that failing to treat an infected, obstructed kidney contributed to his death, this was allowed to happen yet again.
“Despite trust bosses knowing what happened, they did not carry out an investigation.
"This is a clear disregard for public safety and the trust’s apparent claim that they learn from mistakes.
“They clearly didn’t learn after Irene Erhart (a woman from Walney who died in 2011 in another similar case) and now it seems they didn’t learn after dad’s death.
"The GMC should have been made aware of this and we wonder if the patient himself was even made aware of the significance of the mistake."

Comments

Post a Comment

Contact Amy

Name

Email *

Message *

Popular posts from this blog

TRUST BACKS CALLS FOR PUBLIC INQUIRY

New statement from UHMBT chief executive Aaron Cummins Aaron Cummins, Chief Executive of University Hospitals of Morecambe Bay NHS Foundation Trust (UHMBT) said: “I’m pleased that John Woodcock, MP, was able to meet with the Trust yesterday to discuss the concerns raised by a former employee, Consultant Urologist, Peter Duffy. “Peter has raised serious safety concerns in his book and, while we believe all the clinical cases we can identify from the book have been investigated, we want to further reassure ourselves and the public that this has taken place and the necessary action has been taken. “John has been very clear how he feels the Trust is viewed on this matter, appearing ‘closed’ and defensive’ with how we’ve responded to some media queries, particularly Freedom of Information Requests (FOI) and we respect that view. “We have attempted to answer all questions in a timely and honest way in accordance with any applicable regulations and we will now be publishing all
Post a Comment
Read more

Under-fire urologists supporting each other

Urologist's support for ex colleague who is at risk of being struck off As Kavinder Madhra's Medical Practitioners' Tribunal Service hearing continues, following concerns being raised by the General Medical Council, one of his former colleagues has submitted a character reference.  Last month the panel heard Mr Jain, who is also being investigated, has submitted a character reference in support of his former colleague’s bid to continue working as a doctor. Panel chair Julian Weinberg described the reference as ‘complimentary’. Read the full story here
Post a Comment
Read more

EXCLUSIVE: Peter speaks to UHMBT governors

Peter Duffy's heartfelt speech to UHMBT's council of governors On Tuesday December 10th Peter Duffy attended the University Hospitals of Morecambe Bay NHS Foundation Trust's council of governors meeting. This was the first time Peter had addressed an official trust meeting since the publication of his book and the ensuing coverage through my investigation. You can listen to Peter's speech in the video below.
Post a Comment
Read more